Category: Investing Insight

Ideally, Index Funds should just track an index. Its the holy-grail of passive indexing – don’t try to be smart picking stocks, just invest in an index tracking fund and let the market work for you. Index Funds are supposed to only focus on reducing tracking error and fees. The NIFTYBEES ETF does the job pretty well:

Since 2005-01-03, Goldman – Nifty ETF has returned a cumulative 275.22% vs. CNX NIFTY’s cumulative return of 278.36%. Chalk up the difference to asset management fees. But the story with Index Funds offered by leading AMCs is a head scratcher.

IDFC Nifty Fund

Since 2010-05-03, IDFC Nifty Fund-Regular Plan-Growth has returned a cumulative 61.17% vs. CNX NIFTY’s cumulative return of 51.62%.

LIC NOMURA MF Nifty Index Fund

Since 2010-01-04, LIC NOMURA MF Index Fund-Nifty-Growth has returned a cumulative 54.78% vs. CNX NIFTY’s cumulative return of 52.95%.

Taurus Nifty Index Fund

Since 2010-06-21, Taurus Nifty Index Fund – Growth Option has returned a cumulative 46.82% vs. CNX NIFTY’s cumulative return of 52.06%. Oops!

IDBI NIFTY Index Fund

Since 2010-06-30, IDBI NIFTY Index Fund Growth has returned a cumulative 49.48% vs. CNX NIFTY’s cumulative return of 52.25%.

Question

If the NIFTYBEES ETF can track the index with a 0.09% tracking error and an expense ratio of 0.5%, why would anybody invest in any of the NIFTY Index Funds?

You can run the comparison tool here: FundCompare
 
 
 

We ran the Fund Comparison tool to get an idea of how the ICICI Corporate Bond fund stood relative to its peers. Here are some quick takes.

Outperformed GSecs

Since 2013-01-01, IICICI Prudential Corporate Bond Fund has returned a cumulative 14.51% vs. GSEC SUB 3-8’s cumulative return of 10.21%.

Outperformed Principal Debt Opportunities Fund

Since 2012-01-02, ICICI Prudential Corporate Bond Fund has returned a cumulative 25.68% vs. Principal Debt Opportunities Fund’s cumulative return of 24.74%. But ICICI had a deeper drawdown in 2013.

ICICI Prudential Corporate Bond Fund Drawdowns:

Principal Debt Opportunities Fund Drawdowns:

Outperformed UTI Gilt Advantage Fund

Since 2013-01-01, ICICI Prudential Corporate Bond Fund has returned a cumulative 14.51% vs. UTI – GILT ADVANTAGE-LONG TERM’s cumulative return of 12.88% while having a shallower drawdown in 2013: -5.33% vs. -8.18%

Conclusion

The ICICI Prudential Corporate Bond Fund could be attractive to investors looking to benefit from corporate credit improving on the back of a recovering economy and riding the RBI’s expected rate cuts coming down the pike.

You can run the comparison tool here: FundCompare
 
 
 

How do you compare two Mutual Funds and what should be the basis for such a comparison? There is the question of returns, obviously. But higher returns can be achieved by taking on more risk. And then there’s the question of draw-downs. What were the periods of bad performance and how long did it take the asset manager to make up for those losses? How do you compare risk-adjusted returns of two funds? What if you want to compare returns to whatever benchmark index you wanted?

Mutual Fund Comparison Tool

You can compare over 800 funds to each other and any benchmark index you choose. For example, are you confused between ICICI Top 100 and DSP BlackRock Top 100? Punch it in and hit compare.

And as you can see from the wealth chart below, BlackRock’s under-performance has been recent.

However, during the depths of the 2008 crisis, BlackRock managed to go down 51.73% vs. ICICI’s 55.66% and spent 632 days in the red vs. ICICI’s 656 days.

Now, how about comparing ICICI’s Top 100 vs. their own Top 200?

Confused between value funds and midcap index funds? Do famous managers live up to their reputations?

Go ahead, check out the tool: FundCompare