When we analyzed the price targets of various research analysts for last year, this is what we found:
Most ‘BUY’ ratings were on stocks that had already gone up significantly. The previous 100-day returns before a ‘BUY’ was announced were +23.29% (mean) and +21.49% (median). The next 100-day returns of the same set of stocks were +18.24% (mean) / +17.98% (median.)
For stocks rated ‘SELL’, the previous 100-day returns were +16.93%/+18.47% (mean/median). And they ended up under-performing the ‘BUY’ pool of stocks: +12.50%/+14.14%. But only a brave soul would have gone short in 2014. Even the next 5-day returns for ‘SELL’ rated stocks were +1.22%/0.77%.
One can be excused for thinking that analysts were just chasing momentum, given the above summaries.
BUY’s did not seem to have a dominant short-term effect:
5-day : +0.97%/+0.76%
20-day: +3.78%/+2.90%
50-day: +11.03%/+11.40%
On an average, they did out-perform the CNX 100 index. Next 100-day CNX 100 returns:
BUYs: +12.33%/+11.67%
SELLs: +13.23%/+12.04%
Out of the 718 ratings we analyzed for the year 2014, 565 (~79%) were BUYs and 12.25% were SELLs.
It will be interesting to see how they do this year.
You can download the data here.
