Analysis: JSWSTEEL – To Catch A Falling Knife?

The entire steel sector has taken it on the chin lately and JSW Steel [stockquote]JSWSTEEL[/stockquote] is no exception. After making a 52 week high close to Rs. 900 levels, the stock has seen a one-way hammering all the way down to Rs. 600 with its all time low of Rs. 566 in sight.

JSWSTEEL analysis chart

The question on everyone’s mind is when is the slide going to end? It is trading at a PE of ~6.8 while its most recent quarter EPS was 5.76. Also, JSW paid a dividend of Rs. 7.50/share last year and Rs. 12.25 before that. JSW was never a profit engine – historically, net profit and margins have not been that great.

JSW Steel Quarterly results

As you can see from the chart below, RSI at 20 is showing extremely oversold conditions. However MACD is not confirming RSI.

RSI and MACD of JSWSTEEL

Should you catch this falling knife? The answer is wait a while before you take the plunge. With a beta of 1.71, it is pretty volatile and given a choice between JSWSTEEL and TATASTEEL [stockquote]TATASTEEL[/stockquote], I will take Tata Steel for its global footprint and profitability any day. However, keep a close eye on JSW, a good bargain might just be around the corner as the stock races towards its 52 week lows.

There is no such thing as “Risk-Free”

People are afraid, very afraid. The most recent carnage in the stock-market notwithstanding, CNX 100 is back to where it was in September 2010, a very volatile 30 months.

CNX 100: March 2010 - 2013

The conversations I have been having recently typically ends with “I don’t want to take any risk right now, let me wait and watch.” And therein lies the rub – there is no such thing as “risk-free.” Not in life, not in investing. The total risk in this world is a constant – we only transform it by our action or in-action. So let me walk you through what I mean.

“I don’t want to invest in the stock-market right now.”

The most dangerous part of the statement is “right now.” It means that either you, or an Oracle sitting somewhere, can correctly predict the right time to enter and exit the market. Some people have spent their entire lives (and countless computer cycles) to divine market-timing. Ever heard of the Elliott wave principle? Its a beautifully complicated mathematician’s wet-dream come true. Read the Wikipedia article first and then read this Quora thread. Forget market-timing, your odds of dating Deepika Padukone is better.

“I don’t want to invest in stocks.”

I totally agree with you if you are older than 70 years. You have no business investing in stocks or bonds for that matter. Hopefully you have made the right financial decisions so far – focus on spending all that hard earned money on pampering your grand-kids and what not. For the rest of you: bonds, especially in a country like ours, is a bad idea. This is how the benchmark yield curve looks like:

Yield curve

You are basically lending at about 7.5% for 10 years while the historical annual inflation rate is 10%. So essentially you are paying the government 2.5% for the privilege of taking your money. Want to take a walk down the credit-curve? There are NCDs that pay 12% you say? After all, aren’t they called “company fixed deposits?” You should really direct these questions to the holders of Deccan Chronicle, HDIL and Hubtown NCDs (these are the most recent examples of NCDs under default). So NCDs are not all that “risk-free” are they? Remember: the rate differential is meant to compensate you for the risk that you are taking. See how risk got transformed from inflation-risk to credit-risk?

“Can you guarantee that I will not lose money?”

Will anybody write you insurance without a premium? Of course there are ways in which principal can be protected, but that protection will come at a cost. For example, Birla Sun Life has a ULIP that guarantees that you will always buy low and sell high – after taking 10% in fees, every year.

“I will only invest in gold”

The most important thing before “investing” in gold is to know that the price of gold is governed only by the laws of supply and demand, like any other commodity. Sure, the last few years have been kind to the yellow metal – mostly driven by the “fear trade.” But the world is still turning and the sky has not fallen on our heads. Gold is already a major part of assets on Indian household balance-sheets, why double-down especially when the macro thesis is no longer valid?

“I will not invest in anything”

Yup, there was a time, back in 2008, when some nut-jobs withdrew all their money from the bank and kept it under their mattresses. But we are in 2013 now. Inflation has clocked over 10% year-over-year-over-year. Not doing anything is costing you money.

So what should you do? First, understand that there is no such thing as “risk-free.” As long as you are breathing, you will be taking risks – either actively or passively. Knowing what kind of risk you are willing to take is the first step towards coming up with an investment strategy. Once you have an investment strategy in place, draw up a risk-management strategy and stick to it.

And, most importantly, have a look at some of our investment themes – we can help you craft your investment and risk-management strategy. Give us a call!

Analysis: COLPAL

Colgate-Palmolive [stockquote]COLPAL[/stockquote] investors have had a tough 2013. After hitting an all-time high of Rs. 1580, the stock has slid to Rs. 1250 levels – a whopping 21% drop. Investors have been worried about falling sales in spite of holding prices steady and the imminent entry of P&G into the oral-care market. That said, Colgate holds over 54% of the toothpaste market and has been busy expanding its distribution and marketing into rural areas where per capita consumption of toothpaste is half that of urban areas.

COLPAL Technical Chart

We were a short-term buy back in February. However, the technicals this time are giving mixed signals. Our 4-9-18 model has been flipping between buy and sell all of this month and Aroon is stuck in neutral. However, RSI levels seem to be headed toward over-sold levels, suggesting a bounce from support at Rs. 1250 levels is possible.

The stock does pay a fair amount of dividend – Rs. 8/share was recently announced and given that its in the FMCG space, it is more-or-less recession proof. An extremely low beta of 0.16 provides a certain measure of comfort during volatile times.

COLPAL quarterly results

We would be buyer’s if the stock can hold on to its Rs. 1250 support levels over the next few days. Otherwise the next support is around Rs. 1200. This is a good stock to own for long-term buy-and-hold investors at these levels.

Analysis: TATASTEEL

We last took a look at TATASTEEL [stockquote]TATASTEEL[/stockquote] in October last year. We were waiting for a decisive breakout above the (down) trend-line before getting bullish on the stock. It made a 52 week low of Rs. 320 last Friday.

Technical chart of TATASTEEL

As you can see from the chart, the stock has tested the Rs. 320 levels twice before since 2009 and has bounced back each time. From a valuation point of view, it is trading at a PE of ~8 which is on par with its global peers like US Steel and Arcelor Mittal. Plus, the Tatas have been giving a Rs. 12 per share dividend since 2011. However, the global outlook for the metal is bearish, with European steel demand being down by 30%, and the industry remains highly fragmented.

So the question is will TATASTEEL be a good  buy at today’s levels? The RSI indicator is at neutral and MACD is bearish. So from a technical point of view, it is a short-term sell. From a long-term perspective, it is trading at valuations that might be a good entry point for investors who can stomach volatility. If the stock closes above Rs. 320 levels today, it is a long-term buy from our point of view.

Weekly Recap

NIFTY.2013-03-18.2013-03-22

The NIFTY ended on a bearish note, melting down -3.26% for the week.
Biggest losers were RELINFRA (-18.36%), DLF (-15.25%) and JPASSOCIAT (-14.43%).
And the biggest winners were LUPIN (+2.91%), ITC (+1.23%) and HINDUNILVR (+0.11%).fii.2013-03-18.2013-03-22
Decliners eclipsed advancers 47 vs 3

Gold: +1.04%, Banks: -5.67%. Infrastructure: -0.96%,
Net FII flows for the week: $315.10 mm (Equity) and $219.03 mm (Debt)

At the begining of this week we gave a long call for LUPIN in this post.