StockViz

Delayed Entry

In our previous post, we saw how a mechanical expiry-to-expiry short-call NIFTY butterfly with a stop-loss significantly outperformed a non-stop-loss strategy. However, the odds that a stop-loss would be triggered was almost 50%.

In our introductory post on butterflies, we had noted how the strategy P&L gets “pulled” as we get closer to expiry. This implies that during the first half of the trade, the position sits idle. However, the underlying NIFTY index could have already made its move out of the wings and could be on its way back to the center. To avoid this, we can delay entry until, say, 10 days have passed since expiry.

Returns with stop-loss and delayed entry

The odds of a stop-loss being hit remained the same. Even though the total return improved, when you look at the yearly rollups, the hit-rates are sub-par.

Conclusion

Although on the face of it, selling butterflies on the NIFTY sounds attractive – NIFTY is a volatile index and a rising NIFTY will make the moves required for a profitable trade lower – a mechanical backtest did not lead to a strategy that could be applied on an on-going basis.

Stop loss

We saw earlier how infrequent but large losses in the short-call butterfly strategy can wipe out all the past profits earned. To figure out a stop-loss mechanism, we plotted individual expiry-to-expiry butterflies to find out how each one of them behaved. This data is available in the appendix below.

The stop-loss is set at 10 points (x lot-size) for the butterfly. But this kicks in only 10 days before the contracts expire (see how it gets “pulled” here.)

Returns comparison

Here’s the month-over-month returns of a mechanical short-call butterfly strategy with stop-loss:

Here’s the month-over-month returns of a mechanical short-call butterfly strategy without stop-loss:

Because of the stop-loss, the frequency of losses increases but their magnitude decreases. However, stop-losses were hit about half the time.

With stop-loss:

Without stop-loss:

Summary

Applying a stop-loss to a mechanical expiry-to-expiry short call butterfly strategy on the NIFTY seems to enhance returns by cutting out infrequent but large losses. However, the frequency of wins seems low given that only two out of 5 years resulted in net profit. If you did not use a stop-loss, you would have larger gains and would have had more positive years. However, losses in 2010 and 2012 were enough to wipe out all profits and more.

Appendix

https://www.scribd.com/doc/271141815/Nifty-Butterfly