Last month, we took a stab at measuring a fund’s alpha over a basket of ETFs (link.) The rationale was that the index often chosen by the mutual fund is not easily accessible to the investor. We saw how mutual fund alpha varies over time. We then asked the question: What if we just invested in the basket instead of buying the fund?
We did a study of the top 10 equity mutual funds by AUM back in March-2011 and found that 4 out of 10 funds under-performed their ETF baskets and 2 out of 10 funds could be replaced by an ETF basket without compromising too much on returns. That is, only 4 out of 10 fund out-performed the ETF basket setup for them.
The code, inputs and results are on github.