Author: shyam

Weekly Recap

NIFTY.2012-07-16.2012-07-20

The NIFTY ended tepid, moving just +0.49% for the week.
Biggest losers were KOTAKBANK (-6.59%), TATAMOTORS (-5.32%) and RELINFRA (-3.79%).
And the biggest winners were BAJAJ-AUTO (+6.21%), CAIRN (+3.38%) and BHARTIARTL (+2.18%).
Decliners eclipsed advancers 31 vs 19
Gold: +0.22%, Banks: +0.08%. Infrastructure: -0.80%,

Could this be the first of many? Microsoft posted a rare quarterly loss, its first in its 26 years as a public company (WSJ)

Daily news summaries are here.

Understanding Volatility – Part II

imagePreviously, we discussed historical volatility – a measure of volatility already exhibited by the stock. However, history, in and of itself, doesn’t tell you much. There’s another measure, called “Implied Volatility” (IV, for short) that embodies the market’s expectation of future volatility. IV is a useful gauge of the uncertainty “priced-in” by market participants. The chart on the left gives you a comparison between the near maturity IV of ATM calls vs. historical volatility exhibited by INFY.

So what exactly is IV? One of the inputs for the Black–Scholes-Merton model for option pricing is volatility. When you use historical volatility for this input, the price calculated by the model doesn’t match the price at which the market is trading that option. So IV is that value of volatility that brings the output of the BSM in-line with the market price.

How exactly is IV useful? IV allows you to determine a stock’s one-standard deviation move (a stock tends to stay within its one standard deviation move 68% of the time.) If the market is “right”, IV should lead observed (or spot) volatility. So if you plan to hold a stock for less than three months, you should be watching the ATM IVs of the on the run option as well.image

Implied Volatilities are specific to stocks who’s options are traded. It is very hard to generalize the IV of one scrip to a sector or the market. That’s where VIX comes in. India VIX is a volatility index based on the NIFTY Index options. From the best bid-ask prices of NIFTY Options contracts, a volatility figure (%) is calculated which indicates the expected market volatility over the next 30 calendar days. For example, if the VIX is 15, this represents an expected annualized change of 15% over the next 30 days; thus one can infer that the index option markets expect the NIFTY to move up or down 15%/√12 = 4.33% over the next 30-day period.

Implied Volatility and its market aggregate, the VIX, are key gauges that any investor should track on a regular basis. A big variation usually signals “something” is afoot and allows the investor to position himself appropriately. When possible, you should always combine historical volatility and implied volatility to get a true sense of where the underlying stock or index is headed.

Understanding Volatility – Part I

technical analysis chart

Volatility is probably the most widely used but poorly understood concept in finance. When people talk about volatility, they are usually referring to historical volatility. Historical volatility is quite simply, a measure for variation of price over time.

If you look at the chart on the left, you can immediately tell that the stock is highly volatile. The daily candlesticks are long and you see prices break through Bollinger Bands frequently. For an investor, volatility can be, at times, gut wrenching. You might see your stops taken out the day the stock closes up 10%.

Investors in blue-chips might think that they are immune to volatility. That maybe true in bull markets, but in the side-ways/bear that we are in right now, volatility affects everybody.

image

image

By definition, the annualized volatility σ is the standard deviation of the instrument’s yearly logarithmic returns. The math behind calculating volatility gets trickier while adjusting for:

  1. Gaps: if you only use closing prices (close-to-close volatility), then you are not accounting for gap-up and gap-down opens – i.e., stocks don’t necessarily open where they closed the previous day.
  2. Dividend ex-dates: if the stock is paying out significant dividends, when it goes “ex”, your vol will be wrong

What does high volatility have to say about returns? Absolutely nothing. Volatility does not measure the direction of price changes, merely their dispersion. Also, a stock that has a volatility of 1% does not move 1% a day on average. (Taleb)

Side note: At StockViz, we use the Yang and Zhang volatility for stocks and close-to-close estimator for indices.

A sudden spike in volatility can spark a renewed interest in the scrip for speculators and is often used by momentum-chasing strategies to screen for stocks. For example, CMC, SUNDARMFIN, BLUESTARCO and MONSANTO are showing volatilities above their historical averages. Volatilities also spike around earnings seasons, something that option traders take advantage of (more on that later.)

Historical volatilities are important while considering investment/trading decisions. It affects where you put your stops and your time horizon. Higher volatility in long term investments result in a wider distribution of possible final portfolio values, so if you are looking to invest for your retirement, stay away from highly volatile stocks.

Remember: Higher volatility implies higher Risk, and may not come with higher Reward.

IPOs – Are they Worth It?

Warren Buffett had this to say about IPOs: “It’s almost a mathematical impossibility to imagine that, out of the thousands of things for sale on a given day, the most attractively priced is the one being sold by a knowledgeable seller (company insiders) to a less-knowledgeable buyer(investors).”

How have Indian IPO investors fared lately? To answer this question, StockViz analyzed over 250 IPOs since 2010 and compared them to returns that an investor would get if he had bought the Nifty [stockquote]NIFTYBEES[/stockquote] or the Junior Nifty [stockquote]JUNIORBEES[/stockquote] ETFs instead. The headline: over 200 trading days, IPOs on an average tanked -20% while the ETFs were -0.1% and -4.5% over the same period. Obviously, performance varies depending on the scrip and IPOs, as a group, tend to exhibit volatile returns (a standard deviation, σ , of 0.66 vs. Nifty’s 0.12 for 200 day returns.) So much for “buy-and-hold.”

image

How did the “flippers” fare? The 5 and 10-day returns are not that much better either: +0.5% and –1.7% on an average, with the Nifty faring better in both the cases.

image

image

So why buy IPOs at all? If you look at the histograms, there are about 20-30 stocks that gave more than 30% returns. For example, Peria Karamalai [stockquote]PERIATEA[/stockquote] 200-day return is at 300%. Anecdotes about “friends-of-friends” making a killing in IPOs is a powerful motivation indeed.

Is there a way to play IPOs while managing downside risks at the same time? Turns out there is. If it’s a dog stock, you’ll know it before 5 days. Stocks that doubled 20-days from the day of listing exhibited an average return of 65% within the first 5 days. Stocks that doubled 50-days from the day of listing exhibited an average return of 50% within the first 5 days. The rule of thumb is: If it doesn’t pop within the first 5 days, chances are that it never will.

Follow the StockViz 5-day rule for IPOs and add that extra juice to your portfolio!

You can follow IPO related news by using your ipo smart tag: http://stockviz.biz/index.php/tag/ipo/
The spreadsheet analysis for this article is available on scribd.