Author: shyam

HFT vs. Punters

High Frequency Trading (HFT) is the natural evolution of screen based trading which was the natural evolution of open outcry. After completely decimating market makers on the floors of the exchanges, they turned their sights onto price disparities between exchanges. They have been so successful, that the arb no longer exists. Besides, you can only make so much more money once you have to use balloons to create a transatlantic wireless trading line using microwave signals.

In 2009 the entire HFT industry made around $5 billion trading stocks. Last year it made closer to $1 billion. The “profits have collapsed,” says Mark Gorton, the founder of Tower Research Capital, one of the largest and fastest high-frequency trading firms. “The easy money’s gone. We’re doing more things better than ever before and making less money doing it.”

So what’s next for the bots?

Due to a crowding effect in HFT domain and a continuous decrease in profitability a lot of those firms are now moving to momentum, swing and trend-following domains in an effort to recoup their initial investment. Thus, retail traders and fund managers should expect more competition from highly competent and well-capitalized firms with excellent infrastructure and talent. Competition is about to rise significantly.

And this is not a “macro” thing that is not going to affect Indian markets. Algo trading makes up roughly 30% of all trades through NSE. Getco, one of the world’s largest automated traders, received regulatory approval to start operations in India back in March this year.

Expect more competition in traditional timeframes soon but from high-tech participants. The days of the chart trader and the golden cross fund manager are over.

Sources:
Expect More High-Tech Competition
How the Robots Lost: High-Frequency Trading’s Rise and Fall

Hat in hand we wait…

Inflation has been tamed…

inflation trend india
 
… and global commodity prices are flat.
global commodities
 
 
And yet, they (FIIs) fret…
fdi profit repatriation
 
… pulling more and more money out of the economy.
income outflows
 
 
We blamed gold for our Current Account Deficit woes…
india gold savings
 
… while completely messing up our coal, iron ore and fertilizer industries.
cad offset
 
 
And here we are again, hat in hand, hoping that the RBI will cut rates and bail us out… again.

Weekly Recap

NIFTY 50 Heat map

The Nifty ended -1.75% for the week. Financials were the worst hit while IT eked out some gains.

Index Performance

index performance

Top Winners and Losers (CNX 100)

JSWSTEEL +5.53%
GLAXO +5.59%
RCOM +9.49%
MPHASIS -8.89%
UBL -7.26%
TITAN -7.17%
Surprisingly, JSW Steel was one of the best performers – in spite of the macro being unkind to the metals sector in general. And all the talk about HP selling off its stake in MphasiS wasn’t enough for the stock to hold on to its all time highs.

 

ETFs

NIFTYBEES -1.72%
BANKBEES -0.78%
INFRABEES -0.64%
JUNIORBEES -0.15%
PSUBNKBEES +0.19%
GOLDBEES +1.95%
Gold was one of the few bright spots for ETF investors. However, given the recent drop in gold prices given Friday’s NFP numbers, the future for gold does not look all that bright. The slide in USD-INR seem to eclipse other factors for the time being.

 

Advancers-Decliners (CNX 100)

advancers decliners

Bulls beware: the AD line seems to be indicating that the recent rally was probably more smoke than fire.

Yield Curve

I find it hard to believe that short-term rates actually rose. Don’t we have a rate-cut in store this week? Interesting…
yield curve movement

Sector Performance

Here’s a more nuanced break out of what happened over the week across different sectors.
sector performance

Good luck!

Rotation into debt continues

Indian institutional flows into debt has been relentless this year. DIIs have pulled ₹ 12,511 crore from equities and pumped ₹ 2,31,965 crores into debt during Jan-May 2013. It appears that as though the entire market has made a one-way bet that rates are going to fall this year… or have they gone so risk-averse that they have decided to ditch equities completely?

DII fund flows Jan-May 2013

 

FIIs however continued to hoover up equities. Pumping in ₹ 83,206 crores during the same period. Their interest in Indian debt was only a fraction of the domestic appetite.

 

FII flows Jan-May 2013

 

This is interesting because of the questions it raises. Do FIIs think Indian debt is too expensive compared to equities? Are they taking a contrarian stance to domestic institutionals? Is there something wrong with the way our policies are setup that incentivizes foreign investment in equities over debt?

Whatever it maybe, equity investors better pray that FII tide doesn’t turn too quickly.

Previously: The Great Rotation into Debt

 

 

The value of publicly available information is zero

At StockViz, one of the ways in which we help investors is through maintaining “theme” based portfolios, categorized by risk, style, etc. This way, investors can browse through different model portfolios, inspect their historical returns and choose the style that they are comfortable with. This is diametrically opposite of the prevalent practice of “tips”, “calls” and “multi-baggers.”  Michael Harris over at Price Action Lab has an interesting post up about market calls made by analysts that resonated:

 

Anyone who relies on  selective calls made by analysts, no matter how well-known they are or successful they have been, may never profit in the longer-term, since by virtue of the law of large numbers the success rate of those calls will approach asymptotically 50% on the average.

 

I agree with him. Most “analysts” only have a surface knowledge about what they are talking about. And this is made worse by a lack of process.

 

Trading the markets and investing in financial assets for profit should rely on well-defined, reproducible models that have a proven edge. Unless an analyst can prove that he uses a well-defined procedure to generate market calls, he may be instead generating noise based on subjective criteria and possibly cognitive biases.

 

Unfortunately, for most investors, it is extremely difficult to separate out the signal from noise. But you know what they say: nothing worth doing is easy

 

Source: The Net Value of All Market Calls is Exactly Zero